Hotels near Conservation Island

"Great place Just If planning a cook out Make sure you have all the hardware and Maybe some exterior 🔦 "

"Place was very cozy, clean and relaxing"

"The pool and other amenities were great since it did rain"

"Amazing stay definitely returning in the future "

"Had a great time, Dante and Lisa were amazing hosts, hot tub was clean and hot, pool was amazing. Great rooms and lots of space to relax. Breakfast was wonderful definitely be back thanks...."

"It was cozy place, people were really nice and welcoming... We loved the food at Butter."

"Clean room, nice pleasant staff, very nice breakfast!"

"Beautiful place ."

"Clean room, nice bed, good shower"

"Staff was very friendly, and there where a lot of of activities to do around the property, me and my wife really enjoyed our stay here."

"Very nice accommodations with a beautiful lake. "

"The water went ice cold after a shower or two and never was warm again the property was lovely and clean. Room was clean as well "

"I have been around the Lake Wally/Hawley + area for 40yrs (first owning a small summer place on the lake & as a local camp nurse for 20yrs), I always wanted to stay at Settlers--dined there many times--visited the gift shop, even looked into the rooms--finally got the chance--Wonder/Beautiful/Tranquil/Unique!!!"

"Really a fantastic place. Extremely friendly staff that goes out of their way to may your stay enjoyable. Loved the views and waking up to the sound of the cascading waterfall, the large common room with a fireplace and balconies over the stream. Highly recommended. "

"Staff was very helpful, room was very comfortable, location turned out to be inconvenient for activities "