Independent, Edgartown hotels

"This is a road trip to Ed town. I must say lightkeepers in was a delight. They were super responsive. The accommodation was lovely and close to everything."

"The Faraway is our new favorite hotel! I have been coming to the Vineyard for over 25 years and our 4 day staycation at the hotel was the best weekend I have ever had on the island. The location can’t be beat. You are in the heart of Edgartown with everything being in walking distance. The amenities are great and the staff were spectacular. The best part is that the hotel is dog friendly too!"

"Amazing property overlooking the water. We loved how beautiful the grounds were kept, especially all the hydrangeas."

"The rooms we stayed in was small but expected for a boutique . The 3 girls that attended the desk were fabulous. Beds were comfortable. It was great for a short stay. "

"Very friendly staff. Excellent servcie"

"I love how delicately nice and pretty everything in the property is. It's in the best location, with helpful team— near the beach, boutiques, and restaurants. I love their breakfast, too. 💗"

"The Harbor View Hotel is exactly what holiday dreams are made of. The property is absolutely stunning, beautifully maintained with breathtaking views and elegant charm throughout. From the moment we arrived, the staff went above and beyond. Everyone was warm, attentive, and incredibly polite, making us feel truly welcomed. The entire hotel smells amazing, like a luxury spa. Our room was spacious, beautifully decorated, and spotlessly clean. Did I mention how gorgeous the entire property is? Our trip to Martha’s Vineyard wouldn’t have been half as magical without this hotel. It was truly the highlight of our stay. This is hands down the place to stay when visiting the Vineyard. I already can’t wait to return! "

"O.M.G.!!! Perfect in every way! Location, comfortable, clean, everything. The staff are BEYOND kind and accommodating. If you decide to stay here please enjoy- so much to do and at the same time so relaxing. LOVE where you live! "