Saint-Malo Holidays

When spending 465.00 per night, (it was the weekend), I don’t expect to be in a room where the towel rack is falling off the wall and the door frames are chipped and peeling paint. Also the tap water was undrinkable. Way too chlorinated and if we wanted bottled water we had to pay for it. The breakfast was acceptable but nothing special. The furnishings and bedding were also nothing special. I have spent way less money on much nicer accommodations.

We stayed at 42 hotel for 6 nights while helping our daughter move into a nearby apartment. We had lots of luggage and asked several times for help with storing it while we were arranging things and loading it into a van. Every time the staff were incredibly helpful and cheerful, even though it was one of the hottest days Brooklyn has ever seen (102 F). They made the move so much easier than it could have been. Our stay was wonderful as well. The air conditioning was very effective without creating those cold currents in the room that can set off allergies. The bed was comfortable and the eames chair was great for relaxing after carrying things all day. The only thing that wasn't optimal was the cover they put on the mattress had a plastic feel, which made you hot at night. The shower was great and nice amenities. The free breakfast was great as well. We had a choice of different dishes cooked hot by the kitchen, omelettes or pancakes or eggs any way. No avocado toast, I think it wasn't avocado season. The server in the dining room was very friendly and helpful as well, and brought us plenty of coffee and ice water to stock up our bottles for the day. This hotel has lots of nice touches, like prosecco set out in the lobby every evening, and just the best staff ever.

Staff was super friendly and helpful! Room was clean and well appointed. The daily happy hour is three hours long and includes complimentary beer and wine and lite noshes. Breakfast was fantastic and had something for everyone. GREAT location. Subway is just a few steps away. This is our new favorite property in NYC.

Overall, I had a good stay at Sela V Hotel. It’s in a decent neighborhood, and the hotel’s rustic, industrial aesthetic really captures that classic Brooklyn vibe. The design is one of the highlights—it’s stylish, unique, and thoughtfully done. I stayed in one of the rooms with a private terrace, which was a great feature and definitely worth it if you enjoy having some outdoor space. I didn’t eat or drink at the hotel, so I can’t comment on the food or bar. The biggest downsides were comfort and noise. Even with the AC set to 67°F, the room never got cooler than about 76°F, which made it uncomfortably warm for sleeping. Also, the hallways and floors are concrete with no carpeting, so noise travels easily. Throughout the night you can hear people walking, dropping things, and talking. On top of that, the room doors don’t have soft-close mechanisms, so they slam shut every time someone enters or leaves, making it difficult to get a full night’s sleep. If you’re looking for a hotel with a cool Brooklyn aesthetic and don’t mind a livelier, noisier atmosphere, it’s a solid choice. But if you’re a light sleeper or prefer a cooler room, those are definitely things to keep in mind.