Search Windley Key Cottage Rentals

"When I arrived to this property I was told that it was overbooked and I had to stay down the street at a different hotel that was way lower quality! I’m LIVID!"

"I am stunned to read other reviews rating this hotel as clean and nice. Our room was gross. The grout in the bathroom that used to be white was black. The floor in the gym was so filthy that I kept slipping and when I wiped it down with a white towel it turned black. Parts of the furniture in our room were missing."

"I loved the fact we had 2 king beds, the room was above average in size and we weren't far from the marina to go fishing. Will be staying here again! "

"Ocean view is much nicer."

"An amazing resort. Front desk staff was incredible. I got an upgrade to a beautiful suite upon arrival. The property is beautiful. Pools, bars, restaurants, activities, and lots of spaces to sit and relax including gas fire pits and couches for evening wind-down. Loved it! "

"Having a balcony one looking the canal was really nice. And, having two bathrooms in the suite was great."

"This place was far below expectations! Dozens of unsupervised children running around at all hours of the night screaming, party music every night until 2:30am, people banging on the room door all night for fun, shower didn’t drain and left you in 4” of gross water in just a few minutes, room was outdated, had to unplug the tv because it turned itself off and on all night long (never worked properly), no fan in the room or bathroom, and worst of all… we watched a woman proposition a couple in the parking lot for a threesome which later turned out to be the hotel’s cleaning lady. We would have stayed somewhere else but were stuck in the area for a wedding and had nowhere else available. Would not recommend!! "

"Beautiful property and the beach is nice, calm, and quiet. The made to order breakfasts every morning were absolutely amazing and delicious! My only complaint was that we explored Islamorada and did adventures during the day off the property. When we came back after dinnertime, we wanted to use some of the amenities such as fishing or having a drink from the bar and everything closed early (4:00-7:00 it was closed by). Would've been nice to have those things open till dark. "

"Beautiful resort. Property is very well maintained. Wonderful staff. Can’t say enough good things about this place. I will definitely be coming back to this place."