Search Town of Italy Hotels

"Everything was Great. Had a nice Long Weekend, being right on the lake was Fantastic. The back porch was amazing too just relax and see and listen to the lake. The local area was great, the Blue Eagle Bar was Awesome as well as Y Knot, a small Pizza and market, the people were very nice and the food was Great, would definitely recommend the house and those places to dine. "

"It was an interesting area and the rooms were quite spacious. The building seemed to have some improvements. It is an 19th century hotel so it must be an ongoing process. Bathrooms could be cleaner. We loved steeetside porch and 2nd floor porch."

"We enjoyed our stay at Beachcomber. We stayed 2 nights. We loved the live music on Friday and Saturday, grill and restaurant food was great and so were the drinks. Prime spot on the lake!"

"Beautiful setting next to idyllic summer lake town. Melanie Soberon, owner was on site during the days. She and her staff were very helpful, recommending local restaurants and points of interest. Will definitely stay here again!"

"We consider Rodeway to be the best place to stay in the Geneseo area. The rooms are comfortable and provide all the amenities for sleeping away from home. The adjacent dining facility is an added plus"

"Gracious and accommodating- beautiful inn and rooms"

"Beautiful property and nice area. We loved the wood burning fireplace and convenience of the full kitchen. Owners were very accommodating. "

"Clean. Very nice people. We had a check in issue because it went through 2 renting systems. But they were quick to remedy."

"The view was amazing. The property was a cool 70's retro vibe. It was big enough for all 8 of us. Beds could have been more comfortable. The king bed was great but the rest were futon couches and singles with trundles. Not the best for grown adults. Went up on grape festival weekend. Lots to do for sure. "

"We had a great stay. Will stay again. Everything we needed to cook and close to stores and restaurants."