Search Middle Torch Key Cottage Rentals

"We absolutely loved our stay here! I’ll be honest, when I saw the pictures online, I was a little nervous about the beds because they looked like they might be on the cheaper side… but wow, I was so wrong. The beds were unbelievably comfortable — high quality, cozy, supportive, and honestly some of the best sleep I’ve had on a trip. The whole place stayed warm and inviting. The cabin has everything you need: plenty of split units to keep the rooms cool, a full kitchen and full-size refrigerator, and the location is perfect for fishing. They even rent fishing poles and sell bait right in the office, which was super convenient. And one of my absolute favorite parts — the Key deer! They came up every night to visit. It was such a peaceful and magical experience to just sit outside and see them wandering right up near the cabin. It really made the stay feel special and memorable. The only hiccup we had was arriving at about 1:00 a.m. We were originally told we’d be in one building, but the room had been changed and we weren’t notified. It was a little stressful trying to figure out which door was ours in the middle of the night, but once we found the right cabin, everything else was perfect. Other than that hiccup, verything was greatl. We’ll 100% be staying here again the next time we’re in the Keys. This place is definitely a gem! Do be aware that you do have to climb a full set of stairs to get to the houses on stilts which are the duplexes. "

"Very clean room, great condition. We loved the layout of the one bedroom. The view from the balcony was stunning! Would recommend. "

"The room we had, the sombrero, was huge! We love it! Had everything you needed for a stay. We right on the water , beautiful view of the marina. Everything at Captain Pips was perfect, a cute little village feel. The staff was very helpful and friendly. I would definitely recommend anyone to stay here. "

"Excellent for relaxation "

"Always love visiting Marathon. Hotel was very nice…especially like our 1st floor room, close to the pool too."

"Isla Bella Beach Resort was wonderful and perfect in every way in celebration of our 45th Anniversary. "

"I am having a great experience with this property. Most definitely coming more often and staying here again ."

"We enjoyed our three night stay. We dived Looe Key reef every day through their dive shop. Safe shallow diving with excellent storage, easy access and excellent staff. Left the afternoon/evening open to relax or go into town. About 50 minutes from Key West. Recommend car rental for your stay"

"This was an excellent value for the price - the room was spacious and clean, the property was quiet. There was a beautiful view with a balcony. I could not have been happier with my experience!"