Hotels with Swimming Pools in Shelter Island

"Our luxury 2 bedroom suite was very nice, clean, and spacious. We had a huge balcony with a view of the Long Island sound"

"We had a beautiful view of the Marina from our room!"

"Nice place. Recommend."

"Beautiful place, very clean, great staff. Can’t be the proximity to town and right on the water! Left my glasses and they mailed them immediately! "

"Room and view was amazing. All rooms on back of property have balcony ocean view as back building are up on a hill. Gym pool and sauna is a plus. Friendly staff. Some rooms are updated some arent. Not a deal breaker. Our room had a new tiled shower. Kitchen cabinets were of the old brown type. Prices in MTK have tripled in the last few years so we got this one slightly discounted last minute so took it. 3 day stay. 2min walk to beach. Bed was firm. Pillows were on the cheaper flimsy side. Would def stay there again. We usually stay at the Blue or MTK Manor. BC is 0.8 miles away from main street/711 so it is quieter which we liked. Overall 9/10. "

"Beautiful and relaxing! Enjoyed it all! Great service! "

"Food was amazing, bed was so comfy and clean, overall 10/10"

"Barons Cove Inn is very well located i.e. walkable to pretty much everything. It’s also charming, somewhat quirky, clean, comfortable, has very nice room amenities and internet access, a friendly attentive staff, a nice bar and restaurant, a lovely pool, is waterfront and has a great front porch with rockers. What’s not to like? We’ll definitely be making return visits. "

"Need bigger bathroom counters"