Search Siesta Key Cottage Rentals

"We had an amazing time! Loved the resort and enjoyed the pool when we were done with the sand! Definitely worth every penny!!! We are coming back as soon as we can! Thank you 🤗"

"We loved the fact that it was so easy to walk from the property to the beach. That was the main reason we stayed here because of the close proximity to the beach. Only took 2-3 min. at the most to be on the beach. "

"As I booked this trip through Expedia I was at first a little confused/misled at what Siesta Key Island Rentals was. Let me be clear in saying that these are not condo rentals or a hotel, these are not all located in the same area nor do they all have the same amenities! With that said the rental we chose was called “the yellow cabin”. And I can say it was worth every penny. We traveled by plane for this vacay which limited what we were able to bring. I was a little worried about missing out on the beach fun or spending a gazillion dollars on things we would essentially have to leave behind. When I tell you this place supplied everything, I mean it! A beach wagon, umbrella, cooler, beach chairs, sand toys, rafts, boogie boards… there was nothing I wanted for during our time on the beach! The location was quiet and while not on the beach it was a short 200ft walk to the sand! The cottage was adorable, and perfect for our family of 4. Walking distance to a mom and pop grocery store and multiple stores/restaurants while still feeling like we were staying in a quiet little neighborhood. From the owner to the property managers, to the maintenance men, everyone we dealt with was polite and accommodating! Can’t wait to stay again! Thank you! "

"Siesta Key Oyter Bar and The Cottage 1.Quality Foods 2.Affordable prices 3.Service is great"

"Short walk to the beach(5 minutes or so). Would definitely recommend. Quite pool. "

"It’s the best getaway place!! Great beach hotel!! Staff are amazing!!"

"The property was nice, clean and walking distance to everything. The staff was amazing. Super friendly and helpful. "

"An outstanding experience — a place that leaves you with a strong desire to return."

"Beachfront location is great!!"