Hotels in Bay Ho

"Location has it's pros and cons. $70 a night parking fee was a bit ridiculous. I feel like the room prices were decent, but they gouge you with parking so it's an expensive total stay. Location is right next to the stadium so arriving on a game day had major challenges. Street was shut down in front of hotel check in, so I had to drive around for hours to wait for street to open back up. The bathroom was way too dark. As a woman, I need a ton of light for prep."

"Awesome"

"The hotel was very clean, close to the airport and walking distance to a lot of places. We were a big group (9 people /4 rooms) The rooms were very well clean, but all 4 rooms had issues with the shower drain backing up and water spilling out every where. The Starbucks Nextdoor was very nice and a cute delicious bakery across the street was perfect for quick breakfast sandwiches. We were appreciative that we could check in about 45 min earlier, but when we asked for our complimentary water bottle It was an argument at the front desk where they kept saying they were only for VIP guests. As a VIP silver member I received an email saying the 3 rooms I booked would receive the added perk. Now, I don’t care about the water bottle itself, but I like my hotels.com app because you do get additional perks. I shouldn’t have to ask and then tell them I have an email stating I get something and do they want to see it. "

"Breakfast has limited choice and space but overall its fine."

"Within a mile walk to the beach/Boardwalk. It was always able to grab a chair by the pool. Pretty standard hotel room. Took advantage of the discounted water adventures! Found on Expedia and would recommend."

"Clean pool"

"Pool and hot tub have such a beautiful view. Rooms were well stocked with towels and the staff was kind and friendly. Great location on Shelter Island!"

"The room was very clean. We were throughly impressed and would recommend to anyone visiting the area."

"dirty room dirty bedsheet"