Search Fire Island Cottage Rentals

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I stayed at Grove Hotel in Cherry Grove, Fire Island and had an amazing experience! Rob at the front desk gave me such a warm welcome, which set the tone for a peaceful and fun stay. Everything is nearby—just steps to the beach, shops, restaurants, and the Ice Palace, where we enjoyed dancing, shows, and pool parties. The hotel provides beach and pool towels, has an ice machine, and the staff is always friendly and helpful. The DJ was amazing, and the atmosphere was full of energy. The boardwalk is great for walking, and it’s easy to explore nearby towns. This was my third trip here this summer, and every time it feels peaceful, friendly, and full of love. Fire Island is truly a party island on the weekends—such a blast! Highly recommended! I always book in advance through Expedia and find great deals. "

"Property is good. Kabir the night auditor checked me in and made sure to wait because I had multiple flight delays. Even though the person I spoke to on the phone did not put the note in my reservation like he assured me, Kabir was smart enough to wait for me. He was helpful and pleasant. I like that the hotel texted to check on me as well and ask me how my stay was going, never had that happen before! Free breakfast was good. Convenience store could use more items. This was a great stay."

"For a 2 star hotel, I received good service overall. There was one issue when my room was not cleaned, and the staff on duty that night were not very helpful. However, when I spoke with the manager on Monday, the issue was promptly resolved, and I was refunded for that night. I appreciated how it was handled in the "

"The staff was very accommodating. "

"The staff was friendly & helpful, very clean, the pool was amazing "

"The best "

"Nice "

"Very nice area"

"From the outside look, you may be tempted to say “ oh it’s average “ but once you get into the rooms, it’s absolutely great."