Independent, Sanibel Captiva Island hotels

"Fantastic experience. The place is beautifully restored. Lovely room, lovely ground, great beach access with hotel furnished lounge chairs. Perfect stay. "

"Stunning Beach View great Staff "

"Beautifully remodeled, great location, free bikes to use and pet friendly. Loved our stay and wished I would have booked another night. "

"Grounds were beautiful and well kept. Rooms were clean. Entire staff was welcoming and accommodating. Many shopping and dining options near by. "

"Amazing views from Matthews Lodge!!!! This is my third stay (first time after hurricane Ian) and every time the staff, from the office staff to the maintenance team to the housekeeping team are ALL amazing! Always right there to tend to every need with a smile! I don’t think there is ever a day they would ever not make this place feel like home away from home!! The Island Inn is a must and the island would not feel the same without them! They are working hard to re build the future and sustain the incredible history this Inn has to offer its guests. In fact, if I lived close enough, they make the environment so great I would even want to work there! God Bless!! Dawn H"

"The property was very quiet, which it was great for me and my family, we needed it! We were able to celebrate my child's 14th birthday with what he likes the most, the beach and the pool and of course, food!"

"The ocean view 1 minute to the beach"

"The cottage was clean and updated with everything you need, toiletries, kitchen pans and utensils, a full beach cart with everything needed for the beach. I took a few naps in the sun in the hammock. The location is great, an easy block to the beach. The only thing we had difficulty with was the gas grill did not heat up sufficiently to cook burgers. It was an incredible relaxing place for a family vacation, highly recommend it"