Highgate Independent, City Island hotels

"Excellent hotel in a great area. Very near to the start of the Highline with some great dinning options near by. Would definitely stay here again. "

"Here for US Open and love the convenience of the subway. Always a great stay."

"Perfect location for access to Penn station."

"Very nice place to stay. Staff is very kind. Rooms are decently sized. The hotel is in a very convenient area, subway access is around the corner, lots of food options near by. It’s in a chiller area which is nice, but it’s not too far from everything "

"The room was a little small but it was ok. "

"The gentleman at the reception desk could not have been more helpful and friendly! I wish I had gotten his name!"

"Great stay as always my go to New York hotel "

"Great"

"I had a fantastic experience with Public. Air Canada went on strike and only a few us arrived. We booked a suite and they accommodated us to a smaller room and refunded us for the bigger one. Unfortunately the first night, there were a couple fighting the room right next to us. And we told the hotel, they upgraded us to a nicer room the next day and also compensated us for the night before. And I had to stay one extra night and they just let me stay in the same room for a basic room price. Overall the staff were so friendly and I really enjoyed my time there. 5 star! And I will come back again. The only thing is at the restaurant below. The restaurant wasn’t super clean, it had hair on the couches. It doesn’t seem like they do a through clean of the breakfast restaurant. "