Randall's Island Hotels from from S$136

"The entrance keypad needs to be user friendly. The buttons are stiff and I had an emergency and spent 25 mins trying to get the keypad to recognize the entry code"

"I enjoyed staying at Arlo Midtown because the check-in process was easy. They held my bags for me when I needed them to. It was a clean property. I’ve loved the elevators and it was close to the conference I was going to at the Javits Center."

"My daughter and I stayed at the Sheraton Times Square for our weekend visit to the city, and I would absolutely stay there again! It was so walkable to everything we wanted to do, and I really appreciated that we were each given an included bottle of water from the hotel gift shop each day. The room was comfortable and clean, and all of the staff were very kind! The hotel was undergoing renovations during our stay, but we did not experience any noise or disruption. I hope to be able to come back to see what changes were made!"

"older style smallish rooms but clean. Wifi wasn't strong all the time. one lift in the building, so if you were wanting to check out with all your luggage, you were waiting for 20 mins to get a space in the lift. VERY close to the train station, Bus with right outside the door or down the street. Restaurants around Koreatown were amazing. overall very pleased."

"The location is great. Near Port Authority and of course right on 42nd st about a block or two from the hustle of Times Square. It was my first time trying out the Pod hotel franchise and it was a good experience over all with the hotel itself. On our second day, the room next door decided to smoke in their room and it filled my room up with the smell of cigarettes. I had to crack open the window in 30 degree temps in the middle of the night. After 30 mins of that and hotel security coming up to tell who ever it was to stop smoking in the room, my daughter and I just could not bear the smell and freezing cold. I called back and they moved us up another room. I will say it would have been nice for someone to bring us the new room card instead of us having to pack up all of stuff in the middle of the night and in PJs to the front desk for all the other hotel guests to see us looking like fleeing refugees. A bit embarrassing without the back story. Other than that, the rooms are on the small side but every time we come back to the city we don’t spend much time in the room so it was not a big deal. Just wished there was an ice machine somewhere and the option to rent a mini fridge like some hotels have to offer. Each staff member I interacted with was great!! "

"This location was AMAZING!! It’s steps away from Times Square, and we were able to walk almost anywhere in that area. The staff was friendly, and helpful with answering our questions. Definitely recommend this place!!"

"Great breakfast options nearby! "

"Bathroom was small and in need of repairs, check in wait took longer than expected, and an extra facility fee was added when I arrived. "

"We stay here every time we’re in NYC. Love it. The breakfast vouchers are helpful as well. We’re not ones to stay in the room much when we’re on vacation so we don’t require much"