Independent, Chalk Hill hotels

"Very clean and in a convenient location."

"Love the place"

"This was my first time at this hotel, and I've stayed at a few in Calistoga. We were very impressed by the grounds, the pool area, and comforts of the room. Love the extra touches, like fresh fruit infused water and coffee. Lovely backdrop of the mountains. Walking distance to Lincoln Ave. The staff were fantastic- very friendly and accommodating. We would definitely return!"

"A good hotel, nice pool & bar. Good mattresses ! An older property but very well kept, clean & comfortable . Only complain was we thought the $22 a day parking was a bit steep "

"Always stay here"

"Clean and accessible "

"4 stars for the specific categories you asked about, but 5 stars overall because we just really enjoyed being there. Not perfect but so much fun! In particular, re table service in the restaurant, the individual servers were great but the system needs to be improved. We didn't know if we were supposed to get full service or order at the counter and carry out items to our table, so it was awkward. A small matter in an otherwise delightful stay."

"Very clean and nice."

"Stayed for 4 days. Room was clean and everything worked perfectly. The breakfast provided was good with several different choices of food. Location was central to everything we were doing."